Dispute Resolution Department Mission Statement:
To provide arbitration,
mediation and business mediation services to the Court, plaintiffs and defendants interested in using
alternative methods of dispute resolution to effectively resolve litigation.
It is the policy of the Court to encourage the use of Dispute Resolution methods per Local
Rule 21.2. In keeping with this policy, the court has developed and administers several Dispute Resolution methods.
The Dispute Resolution methods are:
- Mediation after Arbitration
- Business Mediation
- Foreclosure Mediation
Why Dispute Resolution?
- Dispute Resolution promotes settlement
- Dispute Resolution is more cost-effective for
taxpayers and litigants than trial
- Dispute Resolution helps expedite the resolution
- Dispute Resolution provides an opportunity for
litigants to be heard and participate in the proceedings,
providing greater litigant satisfaction
- Dispute Resolution allows for the opportunity for creative solutions to resolve disputes.
Arbitration is a formal process in which a panel of attorneys hears evidence and renders an opinion, which
could be binding or non-binding. Implemented in May of 1970, it was one of the pioneer programs in the
United States. Since 1970, almost 70,000 cases have been referred to arbitration.
Arbitrations are conducted pursuant to Local Rule 29.The arbitration process is typically used for cases
where the actual amount in controversy, exclusive of interest and costs, is $50,000 or less per claimant.
The parties may agree to submit cases to Arbitration where the amount in controversy exceeds $50,000 per
A case may be referred to Arbitration at the request of the parties or an order of the Court. An
arbitration award is not binding upon the parties unless agreed upon prior to referral. After an
arbitration is held, the panel issues a Report and Award which becomes a final judgment in 30 days unless
an Appeal is filed. An Appealed case is returned to the court.
The mediation program for Cuyahoga County originated in 1989 and has increased in popularity over the course
of that time. The average settlement rate for cases mediated since 1989 is 48%.
A mediation is conducted by an impartial third party. Both parties and their representatives are present.
The conference is confidential and generally informal. The mediator attempts to help the parties reach a
mutually acceptable solution through group discussion and separate caucuses. The goal is to have the parties
generate their own solutions to resolving their dispute. Unlike an arbitration panel, the mediator is not a
fact finder and has no power to impose a solution on the parties.
A case may be referred to Mediation at the request of the parties or an order of the Court. All the cases
that are referred to arbitration are screened by the court mediator and if mediation is appropriate the
case is scheduled for a mediation.
The Dispute Resolution Department also conducts mediations for Arbitration caes that have been appealed - this is the
Appeal mediation program. These mediations are conducted in a similar manner to the pre-arbitration
mediations described above. Sometimes the parties are in a better position to talk settlement after
they have received an arbitration decision.
This program was implemented in July of 1996. Each year has seen an increase in the demand for business
This program is conducted pursuant to Local Rule 21.2(e) and is for any business case. The Department
maintains a list of qualified business mediators. This list of mediators includes former Cuyahoga
County Common Pleas Judges as well as highly regarded attorneys who have been practicing law in the
business filed for at least twelve years.
The Dispute Resolution Administrator provides the parties with three names of mediators and the parties rank their
selection. The mediator meets with the parties in an attempt to facilitate a settlement. At the conclusion
of the mediation conference the mediator files a Mediation Report with the Dispute Resolution Administrator and the
assigned Judge. The entire process is confidential.
A case may be referred to Business Mediation at the request of the parties or an order of the Court.
The newest method of Dispute Resolution offered by the department is Foreclosure Mediation. This program was implemented in
June 2008. Already the department has seen an overwhelming response to the program. Andrea R. Kinast is the
the program director.
This program is conducted pursuant to Local Rule 21.2(e) and is for foreclosure cases only. The program is
not intended for foreclosure cases involving commercial properties. Parties in foreclosure actions can
request mediation by filling out a request for mediation and returning it to the Dispute Resolution Department, or the
Magistrate handling the case can directly refer the case to mediation.
Once a case is determined to be suitable for mediation, a pre-mediation conference is set. At this time,
both parties are given questionnaires to fill out and return to the Dispute Resolution Department before the mediation
is held. Once the questionnaires and supporting documents have been returned to the court, the mediation
is set. Both the property owner and a representative of the Plaintiff must appear in person, or sanctions,
including dismissal of the action, may be imposed.
The mediator meets with the parties in an attempt to facilitate a settlement. At the conclusion of the
mediation conference the mediator files a Mediation report with the Dispute Resolution Administrator and the assigned
Magistrate. The entire process is confidential. If the case does not settle, it is returned to the
Foreclosure docket for further proceedings
To learn more about the program click here
What type of cases are suitable for Dispute Resolution?
- personal injury claims
- motor vehicle accidents
- property damage
- contract disputes
- employment disputes
- product liability
- legal malpractice
- medical malpractice
- real estate claims
- general business claims
- premises liability claims
Where Is Dispute Resolution?
The Dispute Resolution Department is located on the 10th floor of the Justice Center.
PHONE: (216) 443-8504
FAX: (216) 443-3044